Mishnah Yomit

Join thousands around the world learning just 2 mishnayot a day and finish Shas in under 6 years.

Today: Thursday, November 19th 2026

This Week's Article

Timing the Assessment

Negaim (2:2) | Yisrael Bankier | 15 minutes ago

Recall that we have learnt for a white mark to be considered a nega tzaraat, it must be a particular shade of white. The Mishnah (2:2) teaches that the kohen can only inspect the white mark, to determine whether it is the required shade of white, at certain times of the day. These are the during the morning and afternoon. The Bartenura explains that this is learnt from the pasuk – “le’chol mareh enei ha’kohen”. The Chachamim understand that just as the kohen must have clear vision with no physical impediments, so too the environment must also enable a clear view. If the day was cloudy or it was at midday when the sun is bright, that would also prevent the kohen from performing the assessment accurately. Consequently, the inspection cannot be performed at those times.

The Minchat Chinnuch (169:18) understanding that the law in our Mishnah is specifically regarding the inspection. In other words, the Torah was particular that it is performed when an accurate assessment can be made. The declaration that the individual is tameh or tahor can be performed even at nighttime.

We will learn that if a kohen does not know how to assess the nega, another person who does can make the assessment and instruct the kohen regarding what to say. The Minchat Chinnuch explains once again, that since the Torah was particular that the assessment should be clear, if it was performed by a person with clear vision, even a blind kohen would be able to then declare the individual tameh or tahor based on that assessment.1

The Rambam (Negaim 9:9) however rules that even the declaration of tameh or tahor must also be done during the day.

The Gemara (Sanhedrin 34b) however brings a beraita where R’ Meir cites the pasuk “… and by their word, all disputes and all nega.” He explains that the pasuk connects dinim to negaim. Just as the negaim are only during the daytime, so too passing judgements. The simple understanding of the Gemara is that it is referring to the ruling regarding negaim and not just the inspection.

The Chazon Ish (Negaim 4:5) elaborates. The Gemara required an extra drash to teach, with respect to dinim, that they can be carried out on a cloudy day, inside and other cases which are not allowed for negaim. This implies that without that drash, passing judgement would similarly be restricted. This only really makes sense if our Mishnah is not only talking about the time of the inspection, but also the kohen’s ruling.

The Chazon Ish explains, based on the above, that it must be that the horaah – the ruling – must be done at the time of the re’iyah. It is not just a technical requirement, but rather he says they are chad milta – one and the same. That being the case, he explains that even though an unlearned kohen can be guided by someone else who knows how to assess a nega, he must still see the nega. He therefore disagrees with the Minchat Chinnuch, and the ruling could not be performed by a blind kohen since also needs to see the nega.


1 The Meiri (Sanhedrin 34b) brings that this case is the subject of debate.

Download

Calendar

15 NOV, SUN ה' כסלו
Ohalot 18:6-7
16 NOV, MON ו' כסלו
Ohalot 18:8-9
17 NOV, TUE ז' כסלו
Ohalot 18:10 - Negaim 1:1
18 NOV, WED ח' כסלו
Negaim 1:2-3
19 NOV, THU ט' כסלו
Negaim 1:4-5
20 NOV, FRI י' כסלו
Negaim 1:6-2:1
21 NOV, SAT י"א כסלו
Negaim 2:2-3

Open in Google Calendar